The other day, the following message was posted on
my Facebook page:
"I just heard Beyonce's "Run the World
(Girls)".
The First woman, Eve, that tried to do that, messed things up
for all of us. Adam messed up by obeying his wife rather than God and the world
has been out of order ever since. Only through Christ, His People, especially
the Church, through the Holy Spirit do we have some order in this chaotic,
mixed up, hell-bound world. Beyonce is sadly, disgracefully mistaken. That's
why I thank God for Godly women like my wife,____, my late mother,_____, and
women like you Vanessa and the other godly women of Vision!!!"
I deleted the message. It's VERY difficult to take a
compliment that is prefaced by an insult to another person--especially if that
person is a stranger. The flattery just...well...falls extremely flat.
My first
thought was, "Now what were YOU doing watching a Beyonce video, Reverend?
What exactly did you expect from it, a lesson in Biblical Hermeneutics?"
While I wholeheartedly agree that order is of God,
and best achieved by way of his principles, I'm not so eager to bash Beyonce or
her new song. It stands to reason that my views about it would be different
than the Facebook poster's because I'm not a man. The femininity of a woman is
constantly under scrutiny, or is often identified as the motivation, or excuse
for some guy's unacceptable, unsolicited, criminal behavior--as opposed to
blaming it on his own lack of self-control, missing ethics, and paltry moral
fiber.
The Bible contains the biographies of women who
engaged in questionable behavior, but God used them for his purposes,
nonetheless. If we all knew the WHOLE story of our friends, neighbors and
acquaintances, we might be less apt to consider them "godly", and
more inclined to thank God for his mercy and grace, and gladly extend it to
people whose stories we only learn of courtesy of our TV screens.
Judgment will begin at the House of God. That tells
me that Beyonce might have a better chance of a home in Heaven than the pastor
who wrote the note.
Fortunately, one's salvation is predicated on confession of
who Jesus is, and belief in what God did through him on behalf of humanity.
Many are quick to add a
lot of conditions and extra qualifications to God's plan, because we can't
imagine the depth of God's love for ALL people. We make salvation difficult,
and try to make access to God virtually impossible.
Imagine the thief on the
cross, and how he had lived his entire life before encountering Jesus. In an
instant, he was redeemed. That tells me there's hope for everyone, and everyone
would include Beyonce--and who's to say that she isn't a believer?
We give Eve a bad rap, but she wasn't seeking power.
She already ran her world, and had been given the authority to do so. She just
didn't know it, apparently. She also wasn't alone in her blunder. Adam proved
that he wasn't that bright, either.
Eve didn't order him to eat, or trick him,
and remember, HE was the one to whom God first gave instructions. So just how
well did he communicate those instructions to his wife?
The mistake Eve made,
was entertaining the words of one who envied her, and hated God.
There are a
whole lot of crafty individuals around TODAY doing the same thing to women that
the serpent did. There are power hungry, too familiar, narcissistic, false
prophets misrepresenting the Word of God, and persuading naive, trusting women
to make foolish decisions-- and then turning right around and using their
pulpits to criticize and ridicule the very women to whom they preach! In Eve's
quest to gain wisdom, she did something unwise. She wasn't trying to rule/run
the world (the way Satan desired to), she wanted to be like God--and who knows
what that meant in her brand new mind? Even if her intentions were honorable,
it teaches us that one can have the best of intentions and still be wrong.
Some give Beyonce a bad rap as well, but if nothing
else, she is a testament to hard work and perseverance. Her message is in no
way literal when it comes to "running". Even God said "Have
dominion", but these days, "run" can also be defined in the
following ways:
1. Produce something higher in quality
2. Succeed
3. Do things exceptionally
4. Endeavor to be better
There's nothing wrong with ANY of that, as long as
it doesn't create unreasonable expectations, or an unhealthy sense of self.
Beyonce is a dancer. I've seen more inappropriate
moves, and less clothing displayed by church dance ministries. I don't think
there's anything disgraceful about giving a girl confidence--not just in her
physical attributes, but her personal, professional, educational, and social
potential. I have to admire Beyonce's ability to identify and capitalize on her
own strengths, and suggest that other girls and women do the same. Any girl who
wants to be like her, can't just stop at a good weave, fit body, expensive
clothes, and high heels. One can boast, "Oh, I can do that!", but is one
willing to do the work? That's the danger of wanting to be like ANYONE. You
don't know their back story. They can be one way in public, and quite another
way in private. There are women who only APPEAR to be godly, but please don't
follow them home. You'll be sadly disappointed. There's also danger in
critiquing another person's artistic work. All we see is the finished product,
but we don't see the extent of the time, investment, and sacrifice.
Considering the path Beyonce has taken, the work she
has done, and her popularity in the world, it would be no surprise to find that
she stands by EVERY word she is saying/singing in her song--and rightly so.
When it comes to the standards of the entertainment industry she is a profound
success. She never professed to be anything other than what she is--an
entertainer. I can't always say that
about the self-professed "godly" people among us.
Eve heard that she could be like God from a creature
that Bible itself describes as "more clever, shrewd, and subtle".
Does that mean that as women, we should aspire to be snakes so that we are not
deceived? No. But it does make an excellent case for knowing the word of God,
knowing his voice, and trusting that he knows what's best for us. Eve thought
that merely eating a fruit would improve her condition--not to BE God, but be
LIKE him. Just as it was foolish for her, it's foolish for any girl or woman to
think that being Beyonce, in an instant, is an easy thing. That's why an
imitator's only option is to be superficial and inferior. Whether one wants to
be like God or Beyonce, or both, it takes work.
There's also a bit of sarcasm in her song, as well
as the suggestion to be versatile. I hear, "Be feminine, nurturing,
independent, and powerful. Embrace education AND a loving, committed
relationship with a man, and motherhood. Aspire to be employed, have the means
to support oneself, AND be able to purchase what one likes with one's OWN
money. I don't hear, "You are a god", I hear "Be strong; be
responsible. Have healthy self-worth".
I don't think the song is making any statement
that's dangerous to culture or morals. It's not threatening to the authority of
a man, nor should it be. If a man is threatened by ANY woman, it seems to me
that the proverbial virtuous woman (with HER bad, multi-tasking self), is more
of a threat than any contemporary woman like Beyonce could ever be.
I saw portions of the video. Beyonce is an
entertainer, not a prophet, intellectual, or politician, although, if you look
at the definition of a philosopher, she certainly is one. She's not advocating prostitution, drunkenness,
drug use, or Satan worship. She is a businesswoman and has done well in her
field. She is an artist communicating feelings, ideas, moods and experiences,
through song and dance--not starting a religious movement. At no time does she
deem herself the epitome of godliness, so I tend to respect her a lot more than
some people who self-righteously hail themselves as the pillars of morality. We
should ALL do our respective jobs as well as she does hers! If our daughters
are looking to her for guidance and instruction, or lessons in womanhood, it's
our fault, not hers. If we are competing with Beyonce for the affection and
admiration of our daughters, and condemning her because she has their
attention, that TOO, is our fault.
Perhaps there ARE women who have adopted Beyonce's
new song as an anthem, much in the same way women have proudly sung Peggy Lee's
"I'm A Woman", Dolly Parton's "9 to 5", Helen Reddy's
"I Am Woman", or Chaka's "I'm Every Woman". The lyrics
aren't particularly deep and profound, and there aren't any hidden
conspiratorial messages.
Women in every generation, for whatever
understandable reason, need to feel empowered--even if in their own minds, and
contrary to abusive, seemingly hopeless, or menial situations. If Beyonce's
repetitive song empowers even ONE girl to get up, get moving, rediscover her
dreams, walk away from a loser/user, and reach her true potential, then more
power to her. Perhaps the method she used to deliver the message wouldn't be
fitting for Sunday morning, but I don't know ANY responsible mother who HASN'T
told her daughter that she should be smart, feminine, independent, and
financially responsible. What mother hasn't told her daughter that she is
capable of achieving her goals, is strong, intelligent, great, worthy,
valuable, deserving of the love, respect and care of a good man, an education,
AND a wholesome family life?
Some of the most ungodly people dress to fool the
public. Some of the most mixed up, hell-bound, disorderly places in the world
are NOT the stages on which Beyonce performs, but religious institutions where,
what some women and men do, say, and wear, in the name of the Lord, make
Beyonce look like Mother Teresa.
As a mother of a daughter, I don't find the song
offensive, or threatening to contradict or overshadow any responsible mother's
message to her daughter. Girls, whether they are from Houston or not, need all
the encouragement they can get. So many women are broken, wounded, feeling
rejected, demeaned, defeated, limited, weak, and overwhelmed.
While I prefer to cling to the knowledge that I am
the apple of God's eye, fearfully and wonderfully made, and can do all things
through Christ, Beyonce's catchy cry in her song just might be the shot in the
arm someone needs to get up, ignore naysayers, shake off discouraging words,
reject negative pronouncements, and get moving toward abandoned goals and
dreams. She is a performer. The person responsible for teaching, nurturing,
modeling, and instilling positive ideals in your daughter(s) is you.
I'd like to think that God can use anyone, and anything.